I also have that relationship with Embers! Mostly because I read it before I watched the series so I often have a very hard time detaching myself from even the bits about it I don't like.
(Yeah, that A/N was kind of argh all around, though I can see why she might compare Koizilla to a nuclear weapon -- destroyed lots and lots of people with very little warning, spiritually poisoned the area with their ghosts (at least in Embers-verse), that kind of thing.)
Oh, man - I can see how coming to Avatar-proper through Embers would be ... disorientating, to say the least.
And, yes, I can see the general point when it comes to WMD!Koizilla - it's just the specifics of the Hiroshima comparison are extremely problematic. And while I love the Embers-verse idea of angry ghosts being A Big Problem, I think she was talking about canon!Koizilla, which ... just not nearly as objectionable as she wants it to be, I think. Not that it isn't problematic, of course, oh Avatar and your blissful TV-Y7 glossing-over of massive casualties and collateral damage!
Thinking about it, Koizilla was actually perfect from a propaganda standpoint. "Mum, why is the Avatar bad?" "Because he's blocking the path for world domination he caused the deaths of thousands of people!" I don't know if they ever brought it up in the show or not, but that had to have been the perfect catalyst for the Fire Nation to really go after Aang.
Yep, absolutely - I bet there was some rushed-out Ember Island Players version of the brave, doomed Fire Nation liberators being smashed by the Avatar (well, unless it was all swept under the rug as a blow to Fire Nation standing - but that seems unlikely given the sheer scale of the disaster). And, well, Ozai did respond by sending out Azula!
no subject
Date: 2010-10-01 05:20 pm (UTC)(Yeah, that A/N was kind of argh all around, though I can see why she might compare Koizilla to a nuclear weapon -- destroyed lots and lots of people with very little warning, spiritually poisoned the area with their ghosts (at least in Embers-verse), that kind of thing.)
no subject
Date: 2010-10-01 05:52 pm (UTC)And, yes, I can see the general point when it comes to WMD!Koizilla - it's just the specifics of the Hiroshima comparison are extremely problematic. And while I love the Embers-verse idea of angry ghosts being A Big Problem, I think she was talking about canon!Koizilla, which ... just not nearly as objectionable as she wants it to be, I think. Not that it isn't problematic, of course, oh Avatar and your blissful TV-Y7 glossing-over of massive casualties and collateral damage!
no subject
Date: 2010-10-01 06:35 pm (UTC)he's blocking the path for world dominationhe caused the deaths of thousands of people!" I don't know if they ever brought it up in the show or not, but that had to have been the perfect catalyst for the Fire Nation to really go after Aang.no subject
Date: 2010-10-01 09:12 pm (UTC)